Call for Nominations: 8th Annual Internal Audit Beacon Awards
November 9, 2026On Friday, November 13, the Federal Aviation Administration did something it almost never does. It ordered a nationwide ground stop that halted departures for hours and disrupted travel from coast to coast. Thousands of flights were canceled over the following days, and many travelers spent the weekend stranded in airports.
Officials blamed equipment. Early reports point to a problem that surfaced during a system upgrade and spread across the network. Investigators have not yet confirmed the root cause.
“Equipment failure” doesn’t explain much. Equipment fails every day in every organization. When a single failure can halt a nation’s aviation system, I ask the same question I ask after every major risk or control failure: where were the three lines?
A Note on Terminology
In 2020, while I led The IIA, we replaced the “Three Lines of Defense” with “The Three Lines Model.” We dropped “defense” because governance is about creating value as well as preventing loss. The public and the media still use the old phrase, though, and the question it raises still matters. Each line has a job. I don’t know all the facts of this event, and neither does anyone else yet. The questions are still worth asking.
The First Line: Managing the Change
The first line owns and manages risk day to day. Here that includes the agency’s operations teams and the contractors that run its systems. An upgrade is a change management project, and change is where operational risk tends to concentrate.
If you audit first-line controls, you know the questions to ask. Was the change tested before it went live? Was there a plan to reverse it if something went wrong? Did monitoring detect early warning signs, and did anyone act on them? We don’t yet know the answers in this case. You should definitely ask them about the next major change in your own organization.
The Second Line: Concentration Risk
The second line identifies, monitors, and escalates risk. Reports suggest that critical operations depended heavily on a single system without adequate backup. If that is true, it raises a question about concentration risk that every organization should consider.
A working second line maps single points of failure, assesses their impact, and escalates them until leadership either funds a fix or formally accepts the exposure. Third-party risk management also comes into play. You can outsource operation of a critical system, but you can’t outsource accountability for it. How confident are you that your organization knows which of its vendors could disrupt operations in a single afternoon?
The Third Line: Warnings Without Action
This part is uncomfortable for our profession. According to news reports, concerns about the aging system surfaced for years in reviews, reports, and public warnings. Earlier incidents also offered lessons.
When warnings exist, the question shifts to what happened after them. As a former federal inspector general (chief audit executive), I understood that my job didn’t end when the report went out. Internal auditors have to track remediation, and they have to escalate when management lets a known risk sit beyond the organization’s appetite. How many of your past findings are still open? How many were closed on paper but never fixed?
The Governing Body: Funding and Appetite
The three lines answer to governance authorities, which set risk appetite and decides how much to invest in controls. Officials are now debating how much a full modernization will cost, and they have cautioned that more disruptions are possible until the work is done. That means a known risk will remain in place for some time. Has your board made a similar decision deliberately, or has it made it by default?
Questions to Consider
You don’t need to run an air traffic system to learn from this. I encourage you to discuss these questions with your team:
- Where are our single points of failure? Include the systems that third parties run for you.
- How do we oversee major changes? Ask whether there is an independent review of the plan before go-live.
- What did our past incidents teach us? Confirm that the lessons and risks influenced controls.
- Which known risks remain unremediated? Ask whether the board knows about them, and has elected to accept the risks.
- What is our version of this outage? Ask leadership which single failure could disrupt your operations.
The three lines rarely fail all at once. More often, they fail gradually, through warnings that go unheeded and decisions that get deferred. The time to ask these questions is before your own operations come to a halt.





I welcome your comments via LinkedIn or Twitter (@rfchambers).